Physical Therapists in the WNBA (an update)

The 2021 WNBA Season is under way and the Seattle Storm is off to a great 4-1 start.  Every year, I look forward to seeing opponent staff members I've gotten to know over many years working around the league when they come to town. With last year's season being held in an isolated Wubble (WNBA + Bubble) in Florida, it has been a long time since I've seen some really awesome colleagues and I can't wait to catch up with them.  This also gives me the chance to see how the WNBA is growing and I often wonder if the opportunities for women in Professional Sports Medicine are improving.  

In May 2019, I wrote this blog post which looked at teams having physical therapists in the WNBA compared to the NBA.  At that time, based on team rosters and Google searching, I was able to find only three (out of 12) WNBA teams with physical therapists - the Atlanta Dream had Jess Cohen, a dual credentialed ATC/PT who is now with the Portland Trailblazers (YAY WOMEN IN THE NBA!), Emily Wert with the Minnesota Lynx and the Mayo Clinic, and myself with Seattle. In the NBA at that time, 14/30 teams had PTs on their rosters, many of them dual credentialed (licensed in physical therapy in addition to another area of practice - common in sports are athletic trainers (ATC) or strength and conditioning coaches (CSCS)).  At that time, 3 WNBA teams did not list their Head Athletic Trainers on their team rosters and most did not list team physicians. 

I recently came across this May 2021 (August 2020 online) publication "Gender disparity among NBA and WNBA team physicians," which got me thinking it was time to research for an updated post to see what has changed. The article summarized an October 2019 Google Search for team physicians over the past 10 years in each league, identifying 125 NBA Team Physicians (122 male, 3 female) and 28 WNBA Team Physicians (20 male, 8 female) and also considered the geographical location for these providers. The Northeast Region had the most female providers, but the disparity remained.  The paper cited a previous publication for finding the following:

"In professional sports, O’Reilly et al. demonstrated that 28 of 420 (6.7%) current team physicians were women. Of the 420 physicians included in this study, 224 (53.3%) were orthopedic surgeons. Among those, 14 of 224 (6.3%) were women. The authors also noted that the greatest proportion of female physicians among professional sports leagues was in the Women’s National Basketball Association (WNBA), with 11 female physicians out of 34 (32.4%) as opposed to 3 of 158 (1.9%), 7 of 117 (6.3%), and 11 of 139 (7.9%) team physicians in the National Football League (NFL), National Basketball Association (NBA), and Major League Baseball (MLB) respectively."

I'm pleased to report progress across the WNBA!  In today's search, I started with checking all the team rosters, front office pages, and then went to Google.  I also used LinkedIn to confirm names when it was hard to tell if the findings were current. I can now report that only two WNBA teams do not list a Head Athletic Trainer. Google easily found the Dallas Wing's ATC (Branay Hicks), but the Indiana Fever search came up empty - except their job posting looking to fill the position in April 2021.  It would be unfair of me to ignore that the season is 1 month in and that with COVID challenges and last year in a bubble, a little grace for delayed website updating should be permitted.  

Storm Head Athletic Trainer Caroline Durocher (far left)

Additionally, when specifically looking at ATCs, PTs, and Strength and Conditioning Coaches, the gender spread is now much more women with 18 females and 4 males identified around the league among these three jobs and only two teams have male athletic trainers in the league, now.  (This assumes the Indiana Fever Athletic Trainer is a man, which has historically been true and appeared to be the case when I last watched some clips of their games.) It brings me great joy to see the Seattle Storm with a Head Athletic Trainer, Strength Coach, and Physical Therapist (in addition to massage therapist and acupuncturist and additional providers) who are all women.  Also, big news release today, the Seattle Storm return to a female Head Coach with Noelle Quinn taking charge following the retirement of Dan Hughes.  Moving even further than gender, the number of non-white athletic trainers has also increased and the diversity in that group is noticeable, which is even better!

The biggest difference I've found is the increase in physical therapists around the league. The Las Vegas Aces lead the pack with a dual credentialed PT/ATC (Michelle Anumba) as well as a PT who is also a Certified Strength and Conditioning Coach (CSCS) (Chelsea Ortega).  While I'm trying to help elevate women in sports medicine, Chelsea has a company called "Clinic to Field" which offers a 20+ hours continuing education course, "Comprehensive Management of Sports-Related Concussion" approved for PTs and ATCs.  The Phoenix Mercury also have a PT/CSCS on their staff, Derrick Nillissen.  I think this transition, though slow, is going to be the best thing for the athletes.  Athletic Trainers and Physical Therapists do very different work.  To have the knowledge and skills of both on team staffs can only help improve athletic performance.  

I tried to find the current team physicians, too, but most WNBA teams don't have those listed.  My search was unable to find providers for several teams, but some teams list many.  If the count I found is accurate, I found 12 WNBA team physicians who are male and 5 who are female.  The New York Liberty, who partners with the Hospital for Special Surgery, highlighted their team physician group best.  To be fair - no healthcare provider joins a team medical staff for recognition, so the fact that their names are absent isn't that surprising.  But because these teams create platforms, it seems like one potential way to elevate women in sports medicine from a league who is already doing so much to elevate women in so many different spaces. 

How about progress in the NBA sports medicine staffs? When I looked in 2019, I was able to identify 6 women among the medical providers in the NBA through both their Athletic Trainer and Strength Coaches Associations.  This time around, again from the NBATA and NBSCA listings, I found even more!  From the Athletic Trainer's Group - there were 19 dual credentialed ATC/PT providers and there were 12 women ATCs.  From the Strength and Conditioning Association there were 3 women, bringing the total up to 22 women working in the NBA's sports medicine departments!  This ignores massage therapists, chiropractors, dieticians, dentists, acupuncturists, and many other providers.  This time around, we've got two women with dual designations in the WNBA and NBA with both Chalisa Fonza and Sarah Walls covering the Washington Mystics and Washington Wizards.  Of course, this is all based on what's currently posted on the internet - so it could be outdated-  but it's still better than 2019 which makes me happy.  

Unfortunately, the medical staffs around the WNBA continue to be miniscule in comparison to the NBA. It's hard to compare the numbers because there are so many more teams, but the NBATA has 82 athletic trainers listed for 30 teams.  The WNBA has 12 for 12 teams. And the WNBA providers are still not permitted to participate in the organizations for the NBA's sports medicine providers, which just means we have less access to basketball-related resources and research and knowledge sharing, though the WNBA athletic trainers have also made gains in that area by collectively gathering without their own organization.

I continue to hope that eventually the WNBA will have more providers and will be able to organize league-wide like the big men's leagues all do.  Every year I get a handful of emails and messages from college students asking me how I got to work in the WNBA, and I can see that the interest and aspirations are only getting stronger as the league gains more and more popularity.  I'll continue to try to find ways to help the league, but for now, let's take a moment to be grateful that progress is occurring and be excited for all the women in sports medicine across the WNBA and NBA.

How I Spent My Day

Remember when social media first started to become popular and people started posting on Facebook every little thing they did?  Like folded laundry, took a shower, went to the gym... nothing really out of the ordinary, usual everyday kinds of things?  Like today, my brother just re-posted his first Facebook post of each month of 2019.  How four people liked that is beyond me.  Or remember when AOL Instant Messenger had "Away Messages" that would automatically get sent back to anyone who wrote you because you were away from your computer?

One time in college, I had an "Away Message" up that was a quote from the band "3 Doors Down."  Here's a YouTube link to one of their hits, "Here Without You," in case you need a refresher. I don't remember the quote I used, but it was probably from this song.  Anyways, I had their quote as my away message and I probably didn't have proper punctuation to identify it as a song because my sister called me at 2AM and when I sleepily answered from my own bed in my dorm room, she asked "Who lives 3 doors down from you that you're spending all this time with?"  Ha!

Anyways, now that you are reflecting on all the simple things you used to post on your own social media or the things that annoy you when you read them from others, I'm going to tell you how I spent my day today. An Abby Play-By-Play for your reading enjoyment.  I'm sure you all want to know.

Today is Monday, December 16th.  I woke up around 7:30AM, before my alarm.  I usually don't need my alarm to wake up, so today was no exception.  I have Mondays off and was excited that I had signed up to watch the Breakthrough Summit, a digital leadership conference for women in sports.  If you missed it, you can still watch the replay by signing up here.

LaChina Robinson and Jill Ellis

The Summit kicked off with introduction from ESPN Basketball Analyst LaChina Robinson (Twitter @LaChina Robinson) interviewing Jill Ellis Head Soccer Coach for the 2019 World Cup Champions US Women's Soccer  National Team.  I didn't plan to live tweet quotes from today... but then the inspiring quotes just wouldn't stop coming.  Coach Ellis talked about her career path, things coaches should consider as they work towards the top, her experience working with outspoken professional athletes in the current environment where women are voicing their opinions, loudly, about the inequalities in opportunity, pay, the workforce, and so many other areas.  My favorite quote from this interview was Coach Ellis saying "If I'm the same leader today that I was two years ago, I'm failing."  The value of personal growth is enormous, and I heard her loud and clear.

At this point, I got out of bed and made a bowl of Frosted Flakes with Almond Milk and some grapes which I enjoyed while watching the next portion of the Summit. LaChina had an interesting discussion with a panel coming from three different sports backgrounds.  Dr. Jen Welter (Twitter @jwelter47) is considered to be the first woman who worked in the NFL when she joined the Arizona Cardinals Coaching Staff in 2015 after a successful career as a Pro Footballer herself.  She said she called herself a 'Pro" because they didn't earn enough money for the "fessional" and that when her team won a championship following a 12-0 season, she got her first paycheck along with her championship ring. The check was for $12.  But she was paid to play her sport, football, and that was a big deal.

LaChina and Panel: Jen, Ginny, and Charmelle

Also on the panel was Seattle Storm co-owner Ginny Gilder (Twitter @ginnygilder) who I've previously written about here and who is an Olympian Rower.  What stuck out to me from Ginny's talk was how the Storm ownership group, Force 10 Hoops, initially came together to determine why they wanted to collectively purchase the Seattle Storm.  They wanted to support a team that the community loved, but they also wanted a platform to use to support the changes they saw necessary in the world.  After five years working with the team, I had never heard that story, and now I can't wait to hear more about it.

Third on the panel was Penn State Senior Associate Athletic Director Charmelle Green (Twitter  @charmelle44) who played college softball at Utah and was the only black female athlete on campus at that time.  She talked about her career path and about learning from your mistakes and using them for growth.  Carmelle is also the President-Elect of WeCoach who sponsored this event.  The Vision Statement of WeCoach is "recruitment, advancement, and retention of women coaches of all sports and levels."  Throughout today's event, data was presented showing that female coaches don't stick around as long as their male counterparts.  The data improves if the female coach was, herself, coached by a female coach.  The data also improves if females were asked as student athletes if they would consider coaching as a career after college - compared to those who were never asked to consider that path.  The data was presented in an online live Q+A chat during their lunch session by two of the later presenters.

It was at this point that I unfortunately had to head out for my appointment with my therapist because #mentalhealth.  In the car I listened to the presentation of Felecia Mulkey (Twitter @BaylorAcroCoach), Acrobatics and Tumbling Coach at Baylor University who discussed the process of developing a team culture using Dr. Bruce Tuckman's "Developmental Sequence of Team Development" model.  She uses boundaries, clearly defined expectations, and consequences paired alongside coaching staff congruency to make sure her team functions as a program.  I liked her discussion of how a coach can't really choose the culture of their team, the culture is what the team thinks it is and the coach can impact that culture with how they lead.  Then I had to miss some of the Summit, but it's going to be available in recorded form and I guarantee I'll catch up and watch WNBA All Star playing for the Connecticut Sun, Layshia Clarendon (Twitter @LayshiaC) because she's an awesome human being and I was bummed that I missed it today.

Betsy Butterick

Following mental health came physical health.  I made it to the gym in time to catch my old pal Betsy Butterick, The Coaches' Coach and Communication Specialist. (Twitter @BetsyButterick) with her presentation. What could be more motivating on the treadmill than watching Betsy demonstrating how easy it is to tangle up communications as she was instructed to make a PB&J sandwich.  Something so simple went horribly wrong in a memorable visual presentation.  I first met Betsy in 2007 when I worked for the Connecticut Sun and she worked for the Seattle Storm.  We were both doing laundry for our teams and there was a small group of us around the WNBA at that time who were around the same age, all hoping to find our paths in women's sports. She's paving the road for many behind her and elevating so many coaches with her work, doing amazing things.  We both participated in the Women's Basketball Summit which I wrote about here, and you can check out her latest work here!

I missed the next presentation and a half because I needed amped up music to deadlift, but then saw the second half of the data on women in coaching presented by Dr. Nicole Lavoi (Twitter @DrSportPsych).  Dr. Lavoi is the Director of the Tucker Center for Research on Girls & Women in Sport at the University of Minnesota, but what I did hear was a combination of optimistic room for growth and disbelief at the current status of the NCAA.  It made me sad to hear how few women hold higher up roles in NCAA Intercollegiate Athletics as well as coaching women's teams around the country.  Women in higher ranks will ultimately help women get the jobs in sports they aspire to have, so the future will hopefully have room for more female athletic directors. There are report cards grading athletic departments based on their gender hiring practices.  UConn doesn't look good with their D, but the shining light was seeing my college professor, Dr. Laura Burton, on the Tucker Center staff.  She was always pushing for improved gender opportunities 15 years ago.  I didn't know the Tucker Center existed, but I can't wait to read through some of their research in the upcoming weeks and finish watching her presentation.

LaChina and Holly Warlick

By now I had made it home for a late lunch... I'm sure you're wondering... chicken salad in corn tortillas, taco style. I was able to finish watching the last interview with former Tennessee Lady Vols Women's Basketball Head Coach Holly Warlick, who spoke highly of legendary Women's Basketball Coach Pat Summitt.  Holly's top quote was "You meet the same people on the way up that you do on the way back down, so treat people with respect."  She also gave the advice to young coaches that they really need to love what they're doing.  Coaching is a huge time commitment that requires you to sacrifice time away from your family, so loving it and having family support are essential.

Then I went to Target.

Overall, a pretty awesome day.  I really enjoyed the parts of the Summit I was able to watch and can't wait to fill in the gaps soon.  Hopefully they'll do a repeat next year.  What did you do ttoday?

WNBA Finals Despite the Injuries!

Yesterday was Game 3 of the WNBA Finals. If you're not familiar with this league, the Finals are a best-of-five series which means you need to win three games (out of five) to be crowned champion. Last year, the Seattle Storm swept the Washington Mystics 3-0.  It was glorious!  Right now, the Washington Mystics are 2-1 ahead of the Connecticut Sun, with Game 4 being held tomorrow night at Mohegan Sun Arena in Connecticut.

Why is this important to me?  First, as the physical therapist for the Seattle Storm, I wish the Storm were playing in the Finals and that I was there to watch.  I love basketball and this really is some of the best basketball you can watch.  Haven't been to a WNBA game?  What are you waiting for?!?! Second, despite being dedicated to the team I work with, I'm also a supporter of the league as a whole and have a long history with the teams currently competing.  The current Head Athletic Trainer for the Sun, Rosemary Ragle, was the UConn Women's Basketball Athletic Trainer while I was in college - and also worked with me on my Grad School thesis.  The current Washington Mystics Head Coach, Mike Thibault, hired me to work for the Connecticut Sun when I was graduating from UConn in 2007.  I worked for him - and the Sun - for four seasons before PT School.  Their assistant coaches include his son, Eric Thibault, and former UConn and Connecticut Sun standout and Olympic Gold Medalist Asjha Jones who were both with the Sun when I worked there.  I can't possibly root for one team over the other - though I have a lot more Connecticut Sun t-shirts in my closet than Mystics attire. 

So I'm following the WNBA Finals, watching teams compete for the highest position in Women's Basketball - perhaps falling only behind the glory of an Olympic Gold Medal or World Championship - and the headlines are riddled with descriptions of injuries these players are experiencing.

Like these tweets:

Alyssa Thomas has a torn labrum in BOTH of her shoulders.

Instead of missing games to have surgery, she modified her shot and played through the pain. 👏#WNBAFinals pic.twitter.com/cVkqss0cQz

— espnW (@espnW) October 2, 2019

The @ConnecticutSun say they'll prepare as if @De11eDonne will play Sunday. The @WashMystics have to prepare as if she won't. The MVP's status for Game 3 of @WNBA Finals expected to be announced Saturday. https://t.co/0Vuwyd1R5m

— Mechelle Voepel (@MechelleV) October 4, 2019

Or this article today in The Guardian:

Elena Delle Donne plays through injury to move Mystics one win from WNBA title

• Washington beat Connecticut Sun 91-81, lead series 2-1
• League MVP has a herniated disk pinching nerve in her back

Associated Press

Sun 6 Oct 2019 18.22 EDT

Shares

5

 Elena Delle Donne drives the ball to the basket during Sunday’s game. Photograph: David Butler II/USA Today Sports

"Elena Delle Donne put forth a gutsy effort, playing through a back injury, and Washington beat the Connecticut Sun 94-81 on Sunday to move within a victory of winning the franchise’s first title. The league’s MVP has a herniated disk that is pinching a nerve in her back and was questionable to play in Game 3. She finished with 13 points, hitting five of her six shots and played 26 minutes."

I can't help but thinking - what message does this send to the fans, particularly the young ones?  Is this helpful?  What does it all mean, anyways?

First and foremost, a disclaimer. I am not working with either of these athletes.  I do not know what care they are receiving - but I would bet it's excellent from my years interacting with both organizations.  I care about the health practices around the WNBA and have been trying to help improve their standards for several years - so from the research I've done, I can say with confidence that it is highly likely that these basketball players are being well taken care of. 

Additionally, I absolutely 100% believe that the above-mentioned athletes with injuries are experiencing pain.  I read one account that said that Elena Delle Donne could not sit down because it was too painful, so the medical staff and coaching staff had devised a plan to bring her into their locker room when she was subbed out of the game to keep her moving and stretching and to avoid extended periods of sitting time.   This sounds like EXCELLENT collaboration between a medical and coaching staff and is something other teams should take notice of!  (The Storm is good at this, too, in my opinion!)  If an athlete is reporting pain, I believe that they have it.  All pain is real.  Pain is a personal experience that is influenced by many things.  But pain is also a protector and it doesn't necessarily mean these athletes can't be playing.  Here are my thoughts with what I've read and, more importantly, some thoughts on comments from fans who have opinions on the matter.

1) There are HUGE numbers of people with imaging showing torn labrums in their shoulders and disc herniations that DO NOT have pain.  This paper discusses the labrum tears and found that 55-72% of people without shoulder pain had a labrum tear. (The population was a little older than Alyssa Thomas, aged 45-60, but she is an overhead athlete so this presentation for her is not really that surprising).  Want something more specific to athletes?  This blog post from fellow UConn Graduate and well-known strength and conditioning coach with Major League Baseball players, Eric Cressey, presented the research on the same topic.  He quotes: " Miniaci et al. found that 79% of asymptomatic professional pitchers (28/40) had "abnormal labrum" features and noted that "magnetic resonance imaging of the shoulder in asymptomatic high performance throwing athletes reveals abnormalities that may encompass a spectrum of 'nonclinical' findings." This paper looked at a large sample (3110 subjects) without back pain and found on MRI that 30% of 20-year-olds have disc herniations and that the number increases over time.  This is why sometimes people have surgery but it does nothing to correct their pain... because the MRI findings and the surgical correction does not always fit with the pain.  

2) These are elite level athletes so it concerns me when I read that suggest they're "skipping surgery and playing through pain."  Tissue damage DOES NOT correlate with pain, so unless ESPNw was given reports from the teams stating that they had pre-participation MRIs that were normal and then started having pain the correlated with tissue damage (which goes against a lot of the evidence) a surgery may not even come close to fixing these problems.  Another way of looking at this is - why does their body adapt to present with the MRI findings that they have.  For example (hypothetically) is Alyssa Thomas' upper back too stiff for her to get her arms all the way overhead to shoot and rebound?  Because if that's happening, she's effectively cranking on her labrum to get her arms over head and then a shoulder surgery may fix her labrum, but it doesn't actually fix the initial cause of the problem.  She'll still have a stiff upper back, so it'll only be a matter of time until the labrum is reinjured unless the real underlying cause is addressed.  Why does everyone want people to rush straight to surgery, anyways?  That's painful!  As a physical therapist, my number one goal is to help athletes avoid having any surgery at all.  Sure - if it's necessary, such as in the case of Breanna Stewart having an entirely ruptured Achilles tendon, we're talking about something different.  But what if we just let these athletes recover after a grueling season (next week!).  

3) Can we acknowledge the additional stressors of playing in the WNBA Championships?  It is well known that emotional stress contributes to our experience of pain.  Elena Delle Donne was injured during Game 2 of the WNBA Finals.  Anybody else ever get injured at work and need to finish the shift or wake up with a super stiff neck or spasm in their low back and still have to go to their job the next day?  She has a job to do and it's far more in the spotlight than most people's work.  She'll get her symptoms managed and her pain will likely have a bigger impact on her job than on many other peoples' jobs, but she'll also participate in the conversation of whether or not she plays.  Or at least she'll have her agent do it.  Someone will be advocating on behalf of these players to protect their health. 

Many of the comments online were about how she was forced to play.  We don't really know that!  Any chance these commenters considered that she chose to play once the medical providers told her she would be allowed to?  The reality of this situation is that in less than one week the WNBA season ends, the physical and emotional stresses of the season will be reduced, and a period of relative rest (which means  they don't just curl up in a ball in bed) can begin.  What if they have some injuries, but they're also sleep deprived with elevated cortisol levels from their increased stress, not eating as healthy as usual with their family entourage visiting for the Finals and wanting to eat out?  It's so much more complicated than just "an MRI showed some damage." There will be time to stay away from the basketball court coming soon, time to reduce the amount of stress on their bodies and their minds with decreased physical activity including, less jumping, decreased torsion and load on injured anatomy, maybe some extra napping, some gentle swimming or yoga, and globally allowing the nervous system to calm down.  The Playoffs are three straight weeks of sympathetic Fight or Flight Mode... how about a nice parasympathetic Thanksgiving style dinner that puts you into rest and digest recovery mode?  Maybe we'll see that no surgeries will be needed for any of them!  

4) There are definitely circumstances where an injury to an athlete means they should not play their sport because it puts them at risk for further injury.  For example, after experiencing a concussion, it is dangerous to the athlete's health to compete before all symptoms have entirely resolved.  For example, if an athlete has a broken bone, not only could it be extremely painful to compete, but the athlete is at much worse damage with a subsequent injury.  For example, if an athlete cannot control their bowel or bladder or they have muscle weakness or numbness/tingling into their legs or arms - these can suggest a much bigger problem with the spinal cord. 

But there are many circumstances where an injury to an athlete means they will have pain while they do the things they love, but they may be OK to play with certain precautions.  For example, someone who recently sprained their ankle may be able to play while wearing an ankle brace.  The brace can protect from further injury while they are completing their healing.  For example, in many states it is approved for someone wearing a cast with a broken bone to pad the cast and play sports anyways.  The cast will protect the injured athlete from worse injury and the padding protects opponents from being hurt.  A torn labrum of the shoulder may be associated with a lot of pain for Alyssa Thomas, but is she at risk for any sort of red flag event by playing through it?  No.  And, without knowing the details of Elena Delle Donne's injury, I suspect she's experiencing a lot of back pain without the neurological symptoms into her legs that suggest spinal cord problems and that her medical team has determined it is safe to be playing.  She would not be on the court otherwise.

At the end of the day, tomorrow night could be the final game of the 2019 WNBA Season.  If it is, the Mystics go home with a Championship.  If not, they will play one more game.  I personally want to see all the best players on the court at the top of their performance.  So I'll send up some prayers for these two incredible athletes and role models and to all the other WNBA players currently having pain.  And I'll be rooting for the Sun and Mystics medical providers who will soon get a nice rest break, too. 

Megan Rapinoe Used to Hoop, too!

Summer is here!  The barbecues are starting, fireworks and mini American flags are on sale everywhere, and the sun is finally shining in Seattle with WNBA basketball under way.  I've taken the kayak out already and saw some seals and I've lost and found my sunglasses at least three times with the bipolar nature of the weather in Seattle. I've been working on a blog post about sport specialization for a while, and it has been  moving too slowly for me - primarily because I've been spending a lot less time at my computer and a lot more time in the sunshine when it comes out, but also because other topics just keep popping up that I want to write about. And then I decided I really wanted to write about the United States Women's Soccer Team this week, but... that's what everyone else has been doing.  And so, I decided to combine the two.


First,  I'll start with a definition.  In 2002, Jayanthi et al defined sport specialization as "intensive, year-round training in a single sport at the exclusion of other sports."  This came along with: “The American academy of pediatrics and the American medical society for sports medicine have both discouraged sport specialization before adolescence but acknowledge that this recommendation is largely based on expert opinion...” What does it mean?  It means that medical professionals are supporting playing multiple sports, moving in multiple different ways, participating in unorganized play that isn't a sport at all - just like playing games of tag or riding bikes around the neighborhood, or climbing a tree - so that the body moves in different ways.  

There are considerable benefits to playing sports.  Health benefits, of course, including improved heart rate and blood pressure, cardiovascular endurance, and muscular strength.  There are also mental health benefits, particularly with team sports - but also with individual sports - like community interactions, competitive spirit, sportsmanship, and having a support system.  But there are also risks.  That same article from Jayanthi also found that youth athletes with a higher socioeconomic status were more likely to sport specialize and were also more likely to experience more serious overuse injuries than lower socioeconomic status athletes.  It was also found that those youth athletes who participated in team sports tended to have less frequent overuse injuries than individual sports.

Myer et al provides some interesting statistics about the success from sport specialization: Approximately 30% of American kids specialize in one sport with the goal of earning a scholarship and reaching the professional level in that sport, but only .2-.5% make it to the elite levels. Many parents and, more dangerously, coaches believe that focusing on one sport is the way to reaching this goal.  But using the same patterns over and over again may not help develop resiliency and strength in other movement patterns. 

Some quotes from that paper:

"Single-sport specialization was first reported in Eastern Europe with athletes involved in individual sports such as gymnastics, swimming, diving, and figure skating."

"Vaeyens and colleagues59 reviewed the training history of 2004 Olympians and found that the mean age of sport initiation was 11.5 years."

"At the collegiate level, a study of National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA) Division 1 athletes at one university found that 70% did not specialize in their sport until at least age 12 years, and 88% had participated in more than one sport."

Since I had already been doing research for a blog post on sports specialization, I looked into the roster of the USWNT and all the other sports those athletes played - other than soccer.  Here's what I've found.

Morgan Brian played varsity basketball through her senior year of high school before specializing in soccer.
Adrianna Franch was an all star high school basketball player.
Ashlyn Harris liked to surf and skateboard with her brother.
Tobin Heath reportedly likes tennis and surfing.
Jessica McDonald played four years of high school basketball and was a state champion and record holder in the 400m in track, also participating in the same three sports for two years of junior college before heading to North Carolina where she specialized.  The USWNT has a really long list of Tar Heels and a few Penn State Nittany Lions and Stanford Cardinal grads...I guess those would be the college power houses for women's soccer the way UConn is for women's basketball. 
Alex Morgan is listed as a multi-sport athlete.  As one of the most recognized athletes on the team, I think it's important to note that she tore her ACL when she was 17 and recovered to the extremely high level of play that she currently is at. In this chat, she says she started playing soccer around age 7 or 8, but played volleyball, basketball, and softball as well and didn't start playing club soccer until she was 14 years old.
Alyssa Naeher, my fellow Connecticut native, also played basketball in high school. 
Christen Press, (who I was insanely lucky to sit next to on a flight from Hartford to Chicago last summer in which the entire USWNT was on the plane and Sam Mewis sat behind us) played tennis and ran track before heading to Stanford for college. 
Megan Rapinoe played basketball and ran track.  
Becky Sauerbrunn also played basketball and volleyball. 

Megan Rapinoe celebrating the Storm Championship

Abby Dahlkemper, Tierna Davidson, Crystal Dunn, Julie Ertz, Lindsey Horan, Ali Krieger (did you know Krieger is German for warrior?!), Rose Lavelle, Carli Lloyd, Allie Long, Sam Mewis, Kelley O'Hara, Mallory Pugh, and Emily Sonnett - are not listed to play another sport on wikipedia, though that doesn't mean they didn't or haven't.  It most likely just means they didn't play another sport in high school and specialized before then, perhaps even playing something else through middle school.  Having ten out of 23 players noting what other sports they played until about age 18 has to help demonstrate the value in playing multiple sports!

So, what should we do about it?  We need to advocate for kids to play, to have recess, to move more, and to support participation in more than one sport.  My mentor from PT School, Lindsay DiStefano refers to this as Sport Sampling.  (I'm not sure if she coined this term, but it's the first place I ever heard it, and I like the idea - sample different activiites, find the ones you like, and move more!)  "Parents and educators should help provide opportunities for free unstructured play to improve motor skill development and youth should be encouraged to participate in a variety of sports during their growing years to influence the development of diverse motor skills" again Myer et al. 

And so, it's summer time.  Let your kids go out and play.  Run at the beach, play tag, kick a ball around, throw a frisbee, swim!  Don't let them play the same sports all year round.  And watch other sports too... like basketball, because now it's game time, and I'm off to go watch the Seattle Storm in action, hopefully with soccer star Megan Rapinoe in attendance!

WNBA Injury Summary

Hey everyone!  Happy Fourth of July! Yesterday the Seattle Storm played their "Kid's Day" game, a tradition around the WNBA hosting games early in the day - always a rowdy event with lots of children attending games and singing along with what's going on in the arena.  Today was the first time I've ever head "Baby Shark" at a WNBA game.  I certainly hope it's the last.  If you don't know what that is, it's here for your viewing pleasure, but know that you have been warned: your day is about to be ruined. 

As the Storm Physical Therapist, I have the opportunity to work with some of the players who are injured while they rehab to get back to playing.  This season, the Storm seems to be battling a curse that started in the off-season when Breanna Stewart's ruptured Achilles which I wrote about here, followed by Sue Bird having a knee surgery that was written up in the Seattle Times here. And the list continues after that. There are articles here about Jordin Canada's injury, which she has returned from, and an article here about Jewell Loyd's ankle injury, and an article here, about Kaleena Mosqueda-Lewis injuring her ankle earlier today.  What a mess!  

But I'm not here to write about the Storm Players' injuries (affter all, there are laws against that).  Watching another player getting injured today made me reflective on the woes of the Storm this season and then start looking into the other teams to see how they're faring.  There is a site which lists WNBA injuries, here, which I used for the starting point of this research.  And so, without further ado, my research findings of injuries from around the WNBA.

ATLANTA: 

Angel McCoughtry, a 2x Olympian and WNBA All-Star tore her ACL in August 2018.  Based on typical rehab timelines, I'm not really sure why she hasn't made it back to the court by now - this article and this one from last week both say it's due to strength deficits, which would definitely be a reason to delay returning.  I previously wrote about Angel here when I saw a video of her rehab in the off-season that I found appalling.  I hope things have gotten better for her recovery since they filmed that session.  Earlier this season, Tiffany Hayes had an ankle injury that was written about by High Post Hoops here, but she's been playing through it for the past eleven games.

CHICAGO:

Katie Lou Samuelson has missed all but three games with a broken right wrist.  I recently read this article about her injury where she was working with my long-time friend and the Sky Strength and Conditioning Coach Ann Crosby about all the cardio "Lou" has been doing while she's been casted, hoping to stay in good shape for when she's cut out of the plaster and allowed to start dribbling again.  High Post Hoops also covered Katie Lou and her teammate Jamierra Faulkner who had a knee injury in this article. Faulkner tore her right ACL last July (her left ACL was injured in 2017), and like Angel in Atlanta, appears to have had some complications with her recovery delaying her return to the court.

CONNECTICUT:

Last week, Layshia Clarendon underwent surgery on her ankle, putting her on the injured list for several months.  The Sun, the team I worked for from 2007-2010, posted the news here.  If she recovers on the fastest timeline for her particular surgical procedure, she might be able to step on the court by the end of the WNBA playoffs.  But basically, she's going to be watching a lot of basketball and not playing, which is unfortunate, because she's fun to watch!  With Connecticut winning lots of games right now, if they can manage to stay healthy, I think they'll still be playing in September.  And they have one of the most experienced (and also long-time friend) Head Athletic Trainers in the WNBA, Rosemary Ragle.    

DALLAS: 

It bothers me a little bit that pregnancy is included on the injury list - but they also list players who are unavailable to their teams for overseas basketball commitment, so maybe the list should be called "players who won't dress" rather than being an injured list?  Anyways, Skylar Diggins-Smith had a baby boy in April and is set on returning to the court this season, but hasn't yet.  The team has had so many issues with players being unavailable (Skylar, Glory Johnson in the Eurobasket, and Tayler Hill about to have knee surgery - all listed here) that they were ultimately able to add NCAA WBB Player of the Year Megan Gustafson about three weeks ago.  Even USA today had a little blurb about Tayler Hill having surgery here- and they didn't have a single article during the WNBA Finals last year.  (At least they had no articles in print - maybe there were some online that I didn't see.) And Dallas has Isabelle Harrison back after suffering two concussions early in the season. 

INDIANA: 

Victoria Vivians is out with an ACL injury from overseas during the off-season and Natalie Achonwa missed a game or two with a finger injury, but otherwise, I haven't seen anything about Fever injuries. 

LAS VEGAS: 

Aces center Liz Cambage came in for the season with Achilles tendinitis but has returned to playing.  Point guard Sydney Colson also had a concussion in June but has since returned.  Another crew that's overwhelmingly staying healthier than most. 

LOS ANGELES: 

Team Super Star Candace Parker sat out the first several games of the season after a hamstring injury during a pre-season game, but has returned to the team. Alana Beard also missed about a month of the early portion of the season with a leg injury.  That's two key players missing the first month of the season - so now that they're getting back into the swing of things, it will be interesting to see if LA can turn some of their early season woes around.

MINNESOTA:

Things got so bad in Minnesota, they were approved TWO roster exemptions so they could add players because they are facing multiple season-ending injuries. Two new players on the roster after more than a third of the season is over is incredibly challenging to teach your basketball system and try to build chemistry.  They're having a lot of knee troubles.  Karima Christmas-Kelly hurt her knee and underwent surgery two days ago and is listed as out for the rest of the season. Jessica Shepard is also out for the season with an ACL injury and Seimone Augustus has not yet played in a game this season from a May knee surgery - but she is expected to return at some point.  Damiris Dantas is also out with a calf injury expected to return in about two weeks.  And we don't have to mention the absence of Maya Moore, who is not injured but is pursuing some personal ventures this season... (OK of course I had to mention her)  

NEW YORK:

The NY Liberty mostly has personnel issues due to several team members playing overseas, though they'll be returning shortly.  Rebecca Allan has a finger injury keeping her sidelined and she did not play against us in Seattle yesterday.  New York has had a lot of front office struggles in the news in past years which hopefully are improving now that they have new ownership - so maybe they deserve a break from the injury bug while they try to make positive changes in one of the few remaining cities to have an original WNBA team despite their move away from Madison Square Garden.

PHOENIX: 

In my opinion, the greatest basketball player of all time is Diana Taurasi.  She's also an exceptional human being.  Unfortunately, Diana has been sidelined all season so far following spine surgery, but is tentatively expected to return to the court this week.  Sophie Cunningham had back pain two weeks ago that limited her playing and DeWanna Bonner had an ankle injury last week, but both have returned.

WASHINGTON:

Kiara Leslie underwent a meniscus surgery at the end of May with expectations of about 3-4 months of rehab.  Kristi Toliver had an injury to her right quad and Aerial Powers had an injury to her left glute, but both have made it back to the court.  Superstar Elena Delle Donne has had some lingering issues with her knee since injuring it during the 2018 playoffs, but only missed the earliest games of the season. 

I'm sure I missed other injuries.. and the ones listed above are just the ones I found when google searching - which means these are the athletes that missed a game - or many.  Having been around teams for so long, it's easy to say that most WNBA players are battling nagging aches and pains and are getting regular treatment - either massage or chiropractic care or acupuncture or just spending time in prehab/rehab with the athletic trainer and strength and conditioning coach.  Or in the unlikely event, as I wrote about here, with their physical therapist.  

TAKE HOME MESSAGES:

1) The WNBA is experiencing a lot of injuries this season, and reviewing these articles, they're not just small injuries like ankle sprains removing athletes from 1-2 games.  These are surgical interventions and months-long rehabilitations including year-long recoveries when you consider the Achilles tear for Breanna Stewart and the ACL injuries of Angel McCoughtry and so many others.  

2) It's really hard to know if this rate of injuries and the number of "severe" injuries is more than previous years or not. It looks to me like it's definitely more, at least here in Seattle.  But, from what I've learned in the past two years having had discussions with league representatives about my interest in researching WNBA injuries is that the system by which the league collects injury data has not been monitored or really enforced in many of the previous seasons and there isn't anyone with access who can put this information together into a report. I don't have access.  Teams have to submit their injuries.  Some teams are really good about it.  Others are less diligent.  In my dream world, I'd be taking the data from all the WNBA seasons with injury information in the past and I'd be analyzing it to see what kinds of trends can be identified to try to help with injury prevention programs at the youth, high school, and collegiate levels, with particular focuse on female athletes, but it certainly would not hurt males.  I'd also be working to compare it to the NBA because their work conditions and medical equipment and support staff limitations are so different, it would be interesting to see if any correlations could be found.  Someday I'll figure out how to take this project on and develop meaningful data that can be used to help future WNBA players - and elevate the world of women's sports. Someday.  

3)  How awesome is it that there are so many more news sources reporting on the WNBA!?!?!?!  LOVE THIS!  CBS Sports even posted this article about the Connecticut Sun soaring while all the other teams are figuring out how to deal with their injuries. 

4) There are a lot of former UConn Huskies on this injury list... and while that probably isn't relevant, it is apparent.  Maybe that's because there are so many in the WNBA - or it could be several other reasons.  I won't try to suggest what it could be, but watching UConn basketball players getting injured in college and the WNBA is what drove me to go to PT School in the first place.  I'm feeling a little disheartened that there hasn't been enough progress in injury prevention in these athletes, and potentially we're doing worse in the WNBA.

5) When the Seattle Storm won the championship last season, many of the medical providers felt that the WNBA season is a marathon - not a sprint - and that the team with the least severe and least number of injuries during the season would be the last team standing.  This is part of the game in all sports.  But I'd prefer it if the last team standing, hoisting that awesome WNBA Championship trophy overhead, was the one who had the most talented basketball players with the best chemistry and showed us all how beautiful this game really can be. 

Physical Therapist Board Certification

On a dreary morning in March 2019, shortly after we lost an hour for daylight savings and my internal clock was thrown for a disastrous loop like it does every half-year, I turned off my three alarm clocks which were completely unnecessary because I hadn't slept a wink, crawled out of bed, and drove over to a ProMetrics testing center near my house to complete the Sports Certified Specialist Physical Therapist exam.  I had my photo identification, my registration paperwork, and a list of test day reminders: make sure you remove all jewelry before going through the metal detector, be prepared to pull up your shirt and pants sleeves and have your ears checked, bring water and snacks because your exam is seven hours long but you can have a break in the middle, and a bathroom will be available.

Now, here we are almost the end of June 2019, more than four months later, and today I received the results - I passed my test!  I was walking out of basketball practice with the Storm when I glanced at my phone and saw the email with this report.  Without the Storm, I would not have met the criteria to even take this exam, because you need sideline coverage hours in a contact sport, and lots of them.  I'm so grateful for them.  Per the rules of the examination and ProMetrics, I won't go into any details on the actual content of this test, but I wanted to discuss the preparations I used and what advanced certification as a physical therapist even means.  Fortunately, I wrote many of these thoughts in March, because there's no way I would have remembered them now!  But I couldn't get myself to share it, in case I hadn't actually passed the test!

What does it mean to be a Board Certified Physical Therapist?  Right now, if you go to PT school in the USA, you're going to graduate as a DPT - Doctor of Physical Therapy - but you are a generalist.  You've learned the basics of physical therapy for all the areas of specialty that a physical therapist can work in and you took a big, terrible test that shows you are competent to practice physical therapy.  That test would cover all the different areas of practice and is very broad, covering a lot of topics.  After graduation, a new grad physical therapist will get a job and, with or without intention - begin to specialize.  To some extent, your job may dictate your specialty because that's the area of practice you're going to focus learning about moving forward.   The beauty of this is that you're able to change the area of specialty by working in different settings and pursuing alternative continuing education, but it also means that when we first come out of school - or if we change work settings - we're not very experienced in that care area early on.

When I first graduated, I worked at an adult orthopedic clinic while picking up shifts in a skilled nursing facility.  I focused my learning on orthopedics because it was my interest, but I had to learn the basics of the rehabilitation center because the needs of those patients were different.  Another example - if you came into the rehab gym at Seattle Children's where I work, you would see physical therapists working with children who have developmental conditions, which looks entirely different from what the sports physical therapists, like me are doing.  We're working side by side, all physical therapists, doing entirely different things from the same generalist education. I'm in awe of their work every day... and it's so different!

In some ways, the pathway of a physical therapist mirrors how a physician (MD) completes their schooling.  Any doctor you have seen - your primary care or specialist - went to medical school and graduated as a generalist.  However they can't practice medicine that way.  They are required to continue on their education pathway into a residency, determined by an intense matching program that I'm incredibly thankful I did not have to endure. They will be matched into the field they will pursue and specialize in, like emergency medicine, cardiology, orthopedics, family medicine... that list is super long.  And then, after another several years of working in their specialty while learning on the job, they become a specialized physician and can practice in their field.  But they don't have the wiggle room to wake up in the morning and say - I don't like being a heart doctor anymore, so I'm going to study diabetes and be a doctor for that.  They're a bit more restricted in their careers.

I have read articles recommending that physical therapy transition into the medical school model, requiring residencies to specialize.  This is an option now, but it is not required.  A physical therapist currently has the option to specialize in nine different areas, and this can be done by either completing a residency program and taking a big test, or by meeting a list of requirements and taking the same big test.  This is the test I took earlier this year and have been tortured into waiting four months to get my results. The residency program is meant to give you the hands-on experience and focused training needed to pass the test, but you're able to test without the residency and achieve the same end-goal if you meet specified criteria.

In early 2014 I had applied for residencies in Sports Physical Therapy.  I wanted to work in sports and having had years of experience working with women's basketball and a shortage of physical therapists working with the WNBA, I felt this was the direction I needed to go in.  At the time, I think there were fifteen programs, but only three had options that were not soccer (none had options specific to women's sports) - and those were the programs I decided to apply to.  (No offense soccer, but I'm a fair weather sports girl.  I'll support the USWNT all day long and cheer and attend games when the sun is shining, but a year of sideline coverage in the rain was NOT on my To-Do list.)  And so - I applied to University of Southern California, Ohio State University, and Duke University.  (It would have killed my Husky Heart to be a Blue Devil a little bit, though the education would have been superb at all three institutions).  Needless to say, I was not selected for one of the few slots available, a very sad failure, but a few months later I managed to secure a spot in the WNBA without it, so I took the alternative route. 

The options for physical therapist specialist certification right now are: Cardiovascular/Pulmonary, Clinical Electrophysiology, Geriatrics, Neurology, Oncology, Orthopaedics, Pediatrics, Sports, Wound Management, and Women's Health.  The list of accredited residency programs is here for all the specialties.  A recent presentation I watched discussed focus on making a new specialty for Pain, which has not yet been established, but that seems like an interesting approach to try to advance the use of physical therapists in treating people with persisting pain. Since I've previously written about pain on many occasions, and I work with the Seattle Children's Chronic Pain Team, I'm excited to see if that will be specialty number ten.

A little about preparing for the exam:

The application deadline for the Sports specialty was July 31, 2018 to test in March 2019.  These dates have been consistent annually with all the specialties having application deadlines sometime in July the previous year for a March test date.  That means that if you want to take the test in 2020, you have 1 month to apply - or even less! The application process is pretty complicated for some of the specialties if you haven't completed a residency, so I advise you check it out soon.  All the information you could ever need is right here.

So, once you've applied, the American Board of Physical Therapy Specialties (ABPTS) reviews your qualifications to determine if you're eligible to take the test in your requested area.  That takes about 6 weeks.  I started studying when I applied, but I know others waited to make sure they could even take their exam.  Here's a look at how I prepared.

First, I gathered a bunch of materials to help me determine what content I needed to study.

The materials I used were:
1) The SCS Prep Course from MedBridge Education which has a nice table of contents covering all the content areas on the exam.  They have prep programs specific to many of the specialty areas.
2) I googled "SCS Residency Program Curriculum" on Google.  There are many, but I used this one which outlined a lot of the content topics.
3) I purchased "PT Sports Questions" by Matthew P. Brancaleone PT, DPT, SCS AT, CSCS" a question/answer book off Amazon for $35.
4) I already have my CSCS (Certified Strength and Conditioning Specialist) and the book "Essentials of Strength Training and Conditioning" and the study guide I made when preparing for that test.
5) I borrowed "The Fundamentals of Athletic Training" book from my boss
6) I found my course materials from the Emergency Management Course I took at REI which was a required pre-requisite to take the exam.
7) I borrowed the Manual of Structural Kinesiology from the Seattle Children's Inter Library Loan System for a review of anatomy and biomechanics basics, particularly with regard to the mechanics of the shoulder, and review of throwing motions and gait cycle.  My test was two weeks before giving this presentation at Seattle Children's so I was preparing for both at the same time.
8) Per the recommendations of the curriculum in #2, I secured copies of the National Athletic Training Association Position Statements, all of which are free here as well as many of their consensus statements and several of the APTA Clinical Practice Guidelines here.  The highlight of reading those was seeing how many of my UConn mentors were authors of them, including Lindsay DiStefano, Doug Casa, and Robert Huggins.  Man UConn puts out some amazing stuff!
9) Lastly, and probably most importantly, the Description of Specialty Practice (DSP) for my exam.  The APTA has a breakdown for each exam listing the material that would be covered on it. If you're approved to take the test, they send it to you as part of your application fee.  Or you can buy it before you apply.

Second, I took a practice test.  Right from the start.  The MedBridge Prep Course offered several practice exams that were shorter in duration than the actual test and covered a wide variety of topics.  Based on the results of my first practice test, where some of my outcomes were abysmal, I knew how to prioritize things.

Third, with my current skills clearly identified, and more importantly, my biggest weaknesses, I looked at this ginormous pile of stuff to read and the ~80 hours of online MedBridge videos available, and, I made a study schedule.  This is the same approach I took when studying for the PT licensing exam, so I was optimistic it could be successful again. I tried to cluster things together in a sensible way.  For example, when I read the chapter in the Athletic Training book about weather-related injuries like heat stroke or how to deal with lightning, I also read the NATA position statements related to the chapter, and then watched the Medbridge Video on that same topic.While I was studying the weather-related injuries, two quotes stuck out to me that I had saved for this post  With regard to cold-related illness: "Nobody is dead until they are warm and dead."  So, if you find someone buried in the snow, they're not dead until their body has been warmed up.  And with regard to lightning injuries, "In the contest between people and lightning, lightning always wins." So I got the repetitions for a topics and kept notes on things that I was unfamiliar with or wanted to come back to after I had gone through everything once.  Repetition is helpful for me, but also sometimes felt like I was beating a dead horse by the end of some of the longer (or less interesting) topics.

And then I took my test.  I'll be honest - I was behind on my schedule pretty much from the second week, but I just kept plugging along.  I had an excellent student in the clinic, who I wrote about here and here, and who was treating about half of my case load for several weeks leading up to the test, allowing me more time to devote to reading papers and studying.  I read A LOT of the materials listed above, but found some of it to be too inapplicable to the patient care I typically do, that I decided it was worth leaving out some chapters despite the risk of doing so.  I watched almost every single Medbridge course that was listed in their prep program, several just listening while I was driving, including most of the optional ones.  I was stuck on the Brooklyn Bridge for over an hour in traffic and watched an entire course on nutrition in that time.  And I was certain that I did not pass.  Today's news that I passed was super exciting.  Hopefully writing up my preparations will help someone else on their road to board certification.